Crowdsourcing: A Definition

Late last week I pointed to a Wikipedia entry as evidence that crowdsourcing had become a bonafide neologism. A stronger argument for the term's adoption, however, is that the it's starting to appear without reference to me or the original article in Wired. I couldn't be happier with this development, but I'm also noticing that the word is being used somewhat interchangably with Yochai Benkler's concept of commons-based peer production. Mindful that language is slippery, and meaning itself largely determined by the crowd, I'm content to allow the crowd define the term for itself (in no small part because I'm powerless to stop it.) But I would be remiss if I did not play my own role in that process.

Bruce Sterling, a fellow writer at Wired and one of the biggest brains in the business, rightfully pointed out yesterday that it's a mistake to treat crowdsourcing as a synonym for peer production:

I could spend all day trying to explain how Jeff Howe's "crowdsourcing" has a different structure than "commons-based peer production." This would be no mere academic hairsplitting, either. You see, it's like mapping the mountains and finding two seams of gold. In one, a bunch of hairy-bearded *NIX prospectors are standing hip-deep in the water panning for lumps of gold, while in the other, Three Initial Corporation is data-mining vast spoilage heaps of almost-useless rubble.... I could go on. Others most certainly will.

And indeed, there's no hair-splitting about it. But before I present my definition of the term, I'd like to provide some backstory and context. In January Wired asked me to give a sort of "reporter's notebook" style presentation to some executives. I had recently been looking into common threads behind the ways advertising agencies, TV networks and newspapers were leveraging user-generated content, and picked that for my topic. Later that day I called my editor at Wired, Mark Robinson, and told him I thought there was a broader story that other journalists were missing, ie, that users weren't just making dumb-pet-trick movies, but were poised to contribute in significant and measurable ways in a disparate array of industries. Mark and I agreed that while the fact of peer production itself was becoming well-documented (witness Wired's early, and astute, take on the phenomenon, by Wired editor Thomas Goetz), no one we were aware of had documented the ways in which corporations were employing intelligent networks to put peer production to work. Our emphasis all along was on the verb, not the noun, a telling and revealing distinction.

Thus the term crowdsourcing (a term, for the record, coined jointly by Mark and myself that day, in a fit of back-and-forth wordplay). Simply defined, crowdsourcing represents the act of a company or institution taking a function once performed by employees and outsourcing it to an undefined (and generally large) network of people in the form of an open call. This can take the form of peer-production (when the job is performed collaboratively), but is also often undertaken by sole individuals. The crucial prerequisite is the use of the open call format and the large network of potential laborers.

For the purposes of the article, we set even stricter parameters: We decided we would only look at case studies involving big established companies (like Getty, Viacom and P&G). For the purposes of the blog, I advocate a slightly more inclusive definition. I interpret crowdsourcing to be taking place any time a company makes a choice to employ the crowd to perform labor that could alternatively be performed by an assigned group of employees or contractors, even if the company is just now putting up a shingle. In other words, crowdsourcing need not require an active shift from current employees (or again, contractors) to the crowd; it can start with the crowd.

Finally, a note on provenance: As has been rightfully pointed out, Crowdsourcing owes a debt to James Surowiecki's eye-opening and entertaining book, The Wisdom of Crowds. But as Suowiecki himself notes in that book, we both owe a further debt to Charles Mackay's Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, a work from the early Victorian era that should be required reading for anyone interested in the subject.

Comments

[Alan]

Thanks for the up-date Jeff. I found it interesting when searching for examples of crowdsourcing to find examples of an economic nature that quite frankly appear to be negative forms of the concept, for me at least. In short, large organizations using the method to by-pass the burdens of, health benefits, paid holidays unions and all the other overheads that come with more traditional forms of employee/employer relationships. I say negative because that is basically using the principle to cut expenditures, anyway an economic engine that is already in overdrive, and “use” the crowd principle purely based on economic gain! The question that arises for me is age old and applies to most already existing forms of the above-defined relationships. It is of a moral/rights nature and I would suggest that the evolving market place should also be evolving on principles that are healthy for the larger community. One might find such a statement naive but it is, in my mind, central the long-term health of the “social order.” The use of crowdsourcing for purely economic gain is the antithesis of what should be evolving along with what new technologies are making possible. The question is, who is going to take on that responsibility? It appears to me that in a point in the middle of a circle image, with the point being those who are exerting economic gain and the circle being the crowd, that the circle might have to provide moral responsibility to the process because the point has already demonstrated that it’s not going to happen. This all might sound rather esoteric but surely important for long term societal health. Rome did not fall in a day but it fell!

I am very interested in how the crowd might use crowdsourcing and wonder if there is any forward looking person out there who might have some ideas!

Jeff, did you catch anything? Alan.

[Edwyn Chan]

Jeff your article is great. I just blogged about it. too bad you don;t have trackback on your blog. I think crowdsourcing is sort of an inverse of longtail. what do you think?

[Theo]

I don't think many Americans fully comprehend just how disruptive this idea really is. It has the potential to be far more disruptive than outsourcing because it provides the mechanism to unleash the creative abilities of millions of entrepreneurs outside the USA that have never been able to overcome the structural economic deficiencies in their own countries.

Two articles that have a bearing on this subject that may be of interest to people interested in the subject:

The Rise of the Creative Class by Richard Florida
http://www.creativeclass.org/_flight_riseoverview.shtml

Can You Survive the Ebay Economy?
http://www.inc.com/magazine/20000301/17295.html

[JeffPHowe]

Thanks Theo ... These are indeed great resources. I agree that crowdsourcing could be more disruptive than people realize. It could also foster more economic growth than people realize. But I have too much humility to forecast either of those outcomes with anything approaching surety. For instance, has everyone seen the numbers released in a Pali Research report on digital music sales? No one, to my knowledge, was forecasting a plateuing of growth this early in the game.

[Lyndon]

No need to go to Amazon or any other bookshop to buy Charles Mackay's 'Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds' - when there it is available for free from Project Gutenberg - http://www.gutenberg.org/browse/authors/m#a516

[josh]

I am not sure I understand how crowdsourcing will work with businesses that are not necesarily incentive driven, like the T-shirt company. What is going to motivate people to crowdsource when it isn't facebook, or a free t-shirt they are getting?

[myspace design]

Stumbled upon your website. Interesting stuff you got here. I enjoyed reading some of your posts. Will be back for more, definitely.

[John Beck Real Estate]

This blog Is very informative , I am really pleased to post my comment on this blog . It helped me with ocean of knowledge so I really belive you will do much better in the future . Good job web master .
http://www.taxforeclosurecurrentevents.com/

[Acomplia]

Web master has done a very good job,this site is very interesting and inovative , and i have an experience you can easily get what to you want to know with the help of this site.
http://www.weightlossproductz.com

[Penis Enlargement, Pills, - Penis Size Enhancement]

Many men all around the globe are in a state of complexes of not having the sufficient penis size, just imagine the embracement when you are up for a girl and your impotent penis size kills your hysteria. They very rightly says that ‘half of a dick is the sign of impotent' so what for waiting when the supreme enlargement pills are there to assist you at the time when you most needed them to show your indelible masculinity.

There are so many other enlargement pills are available in the market which claim to be high agile and effective but in-spite are some major side effect has been found due to their usage, such as losing of sensation in your peripheral nerve is vital; beside it makes your organ faded.

Feeling Insecure about penis size?

There is a tremendous amount of pressure on our sexual performances. This pressure is applied from a number of sources, from the media to perhaps even our partners. While women complain about pressure to have an orgasm during intercourse, the modern man has a lot to worry about himself.

After all, women associate larger penis size in men with increased sexual expertise. Although at first sight a woman has no way of telling your “size”, the mere worry about how your partner will judge your endowment will affect your performance even before reaching the bedroom.

[folligen]

Thank you for the introduction to the new outsourcing concept that you have defined as crowdsourcing – interesting approach

[ziektekostenverzekering]

It really makes me to feel good whenever I see the interesting blog like this.Thanks

[lose weight fast and easy]

Awesome post as always!

[Kamagra Discount]

i really like your post.. thanks!

[Tadalafil]

That's a interesting site about the Crowdsourcing, please if you can publish more info just do it because it's so useful. Also is really important that you know the european company noted that Tadalafil,an oral medication for the treatment of erectile dysfunction http://www.xlpharmacy.com

[No Prescription]

I will continue to order generic viagra and I hope that all men who suffer from sexual impotence will do so as well, since to order No Prescription online is the best idea to save up a couple of dollars.

[Gay Rape]

I don't think many Americans fully comprehend just how disruptive this idea really is. It has the potential to be far more disruptive than outsourcing because it provides the mechanism to unleash the creative abilities of millions of entrepreneurs outside the USA that have never been able to overcome the structural economic deficiencies in their own countries.

[WEIGHT LOSS]

Health and fitness is always a person's prime concern today's hectic lifestyle and fast-paced society. And to maintain and sustain a good figure, you need to follow strict dietary regimen and exercise routine. Obesity is a global concern and excess weight loss can lead a person to host of diseases. After all health matters most!
HI ,VISIT NOW SITE :
http://www.pro-weight-loss.com

[john1]

Mmm interesting subject and comments.I learned what Crowdsourcing is from here.I am interested in weight loss and fitness.What we recommend at our website abcweightloss.net for obese people is to do regular exercise and suitable diet for permanent weight loss.

[vigrx]

Yes this is very interesting
http://www.1vigrxplus.com

[vimax]

Nice information this is really interesting
http://www.buyvimaxpills.com

[jack]

http://www.china-satibo.com
Male enhancement pills, sex health, penis enlargement,herbal medicine sexual endurance, impotence, erectile dysfunction, erection problems, fertility, low sex drive, premature ejaculation, sperm volume enhancers, sexual health
Exotica-T6 is an all-natural female sexual stimulant,used for enhancing women's libido.
Specially formulated to raise female sex drive, increase libido, and enable better orgasm, Exotica-T6 can help to enhance sexual sensitivity, increase sexual stamina, increase sexual desire, and improve your ability to achieve more frequent and more powerful multiple orgasms.
http://www.china-satibo.com/news/Exotica-T6.html
http://www.china-satibo.com/news/LibidoCoffee.html
http://www.china-satibo.com/news/FlowerJuice.html
www china-satibo com
www china-satibo com
www china-satibo com

[jack]

http://www.china-satibo.com
Supernatural WR pill is the famous blue pill that treats erectile dysfunction, it acts by increasing the blood flow in the penis to give a strong erection and more pleasure during sexual intercourse.
The Supernatural WR pill is an alternative pill which thanks to its cost and effectiveness has managed to succeed in the pharmaceutical market. Ask your doctor or pharmacist, they will tell you about its effectiveness.
Just take 1 pill 15 minutes to 30 minutes before sexual intercourse, then you will notice a very strong erection of your penis, the erection can last up to 4 hours.
Supernatural WR pill is known to:
1: Increase Sex Drive
2: Boost Sexual Performance
3: Fuller & Harder Erections
4: Increase Stamina & Endurance
5: Quicker Recharges
http://www.china-satibo.com
http://www.china-satibo.com/7.htm
http://www.china-satibo.com/6.htm
www china-satibo com
www china-satibo com
www china-satibo com

[Buy Avodart]

Are you looking for a bodyguard for enlarged prostate? Then what can be better rather than Avodart for a terrific disease like this. You can win the battle of enlarged prostate with this triumphant medicine

[プロペシア]

Are you looking for a bodyguard for enlarged prostate? Then what can be better rather than Avodart for a terrific disease like this. You can win the battle of enlarged prostate with this triumphant medicine.